Marketing
Verified by Toolspoke

Creative fatigue watch

By Toolspoke

Twice a week, flags Meta ads shown too often whose click rate is falling, checks their landing pages in GA4, and posts to Slack.

Needs a Toolspoke account. You choose which project it installs into.

An illustration with made-up examples. It is not a recording.
Meta Ads + Google Analytics + Slack
Required integrations
Runs on a schedule
Mondays and Thursdays at 9am by default
Post one message
What its last step does
Some actions can delete
2 of 42 actions in its tools
On this page
  1. The short version
  2. What it will never do
  3. What Creative fatigue watch does
  4. How it works
  5. What a Monday list looks like
  6. Who uses Creative fatigue watch
  7. What it connects to
  8. When it runs
  9. How to set it up
  10. Make Creative fatigue watch fit your account
  11. Compared with other options
  12. Questions
  13. Related agents

The short version

What it is
A ready-made Toolspoke agent that spots worn-out Meta ads before they waste a week of spend.
What it reads
Ad-level frequency, click rate, CPM and spend for the last 7 days and the 7 before, and GA4 engagement for the visits each ad sent.
Where it posts
One Slack channel, with the tired ads ranked by spend.
What it flags
Live ads whose frequency is 3.5 or more and whose click rate fell by a quarter or more on the week before.
How often
Mondays and Thursdays at 9am once you switch it on.
What it never does
Pause a campaign or change an ad, ad set, budget or audience.
What you need
A Toolspoke account, a Meta ad account, a GA4 property and a Slack workspace.

What Creative fatigue watch will never do

Creative fatigue watch is told never to pause a campaign or change an ad, and with read access to Meta it cannot. It shows the numbers and you decide.

Creative fatigue watch will never

  • Pause a campaign, or change an ad, ad set, budget or audience.
  • Promise what a new creative will do.
  • Add Meta's clicks and Analytics' sessions together or treat them as the same count.
  • Post to anyone directly, or edit an earlier post.

Why it does not pause

A tired ad still brings some sales, and pausing it before the replacement is live can cost more than the fatigue. Only the person running the account knows what is ready to go.

Why it gives numbers, not promises

A falling click rate says the ad is wearing out. It does not say what a new one will do.

A flag that promisesReplace video 2 and your CTR will be back above 1% this week.
What this agent writes insteadFrequency 5.1. CTR 1.04% to 0.62%. Landing page engagement held at 58%.

Why it keeps the counts apart

Meta counts clicks and Analytics counts sessions, and they never match. The post shows each beside the other, never added together.

These are written into Creative fatigue watch's instructions. They guide the agent, but they are not a permission. What it is allowed to touch is set by the access you grant.

Creative fatigue watch reads your ads and your site and says which creative is worn. Every change in Ads Manager stays with you.

What Creative fatigue watch does

Creative fatigue watch is an AI agent that reads your Meta ad results twice a week, finds the ads the same people have seen too often while fewer of them click, checks in Google Analytics whether the visits those ads send still engage, and posts the list to Slack.

Ads wear out. The audience sees the same video for the fifth time, the click rate slides and each thousand impressions costs more. It shows in Ads Manager, but only if someone compares this week with last week ad by ad.

Ad set totals hide it. One tired ad can sit inside an ad set that still looks fine.

Creative fatigue watch makes the comparison for every live ad on Monday and Thursday. When an ad looks tired, it checks Google Analytics for the visits it sent, so you can tell a worn creative from a landing page problem.

In practice, twice a week you get:

  • Live ads with high frequency and a falling click rate, ranked by spend
  • CPM this week against last, for each flagged ad
  • Landing page engagement for the visits each ad sent
  • Ads to watch: high frequency, click rate still steady

How it works

Creative fatigue watch works in four steps on Mondays and Thursdays: it reads ad results for two weeks, flags the tired ads, checks their visits in Analytics and posts one list. All of it comes from the agent's written instructions, which you can read and edit after you install it.

  1. Step 1: Read every live ad

    It reads frequency, click rate, CPM and spend for this week and last.

  2. Step 2: Flag the tired ones

    High frequency and a click rate down a quarter, with enough impressions to judge.

  3. Step 3: Check the landing page

    It reads engagement for the visits each flagged ad sent.

  4. Step 4: Post the list

    It posts the tired ads ranked by spend, then the ones to watch.

Drawn from this agent's own tools and instructions. It is not a recording of a run.

It reads Meta at ad level

It calls get_insights with level set to ad for the 7 days ending yesterday and the 7 before, asking for frequency, click rate, CPM, reach and spend. It checks list_ads so only live ads are judged.

It needs enough data to judge

An ad needs at least 1,000 impressions in each week to be flagged. One with high frequency but a steady click rate is listed to watch, not called tired.

It matches ads to Analytics by tag

Meta's results do not carry the landing page. So it uses run_report on your GA4 property, filtered on the UTM tag your ads carry, for sessions, engagement rate and key events. If a field is refused, it checks with check_compatibility.

It flags and stops

It never pauses an ad or changes a budget. Choosing a new creative is your call. The limits are under what it will never do.

What a Monday list looks like

A message from Creative fatigue watch is one Slack post: the tired ads ranked by spend, each with the Meta numbers and the landing page engagement side by side.

Wren & Oak

Channels

  • # paid-social
  • # marketing
  • # growth
  • # general

# paid-social

Creative fatigue watchAPP9:00 AM

Monday. 20 to 26 October against 13 to 19 October. 38 live ads read. High frequency means 3.5, the default.

Tired (2)

  • Spring sale, video 2 (Prospecting UK). Frequency 5.1. CTR 1.04% to 0.62%. CPM 7.20 to 9.85. Spend 1,240. Landing page engagement held at 58%, so the creative is the likely cause.
  • Retarget, carousel A (Site visitors 30d). Frequency 4.4. CTR 1.30% to 0.81%. CPM 11.10 to 12.40. Spend 690. Engagement fell 61% to 44%: check the page too.

To watch (1)

  • Prospecting, static 3. Frequency 3.8, CTR steady at 0.95%.

The rest

35 live ads showed no sign. 4 had too few impressions to judge.

One message, posted on Monday at 9:00 AM. The brand, ads and amounts are made up.
Tired

Ads with high frequency and a click rate down by a quarter or more. The engagement line says whether the page is likely part of the problem.

To watch

Ads with high frequency whose click rate has not fallen yet. They are next.

The rest

How many live ads showed no sign and how many were too small to judge, so the list is never mistaken for the account.

When nothing is tired

If no ad is flagged, Creative fatigue watch posts one line saying so and how many ads it checked.

A failed run is different. If Meta cannot be read, it posts that once. If Analytics cannot be read, it flags from Meta alone and says the landing page checks were skipped.

Who uses Creative fatigue watch

Creative fatigue watch suits teams that run Meta ads and track visits in Google Analytics 4. The examples use made-up names.

A paid social manager

Isla Moreno runs forty ads across six ad sets. The list tells her which creative to replace before the week's budget goes on it.

In their listNeeds youSpring sale, video 2. Frequency 5.1. CTR 1.04% to 0.62%.

A designer planning the next batch

Kofi Mensah makes the creatives. The watch list tells him which ones will need a replacement soon.

In their listWorth knowingProspecting, static 3. Frequency 3.8, CTR steady.

A growth lead watching conversion

Anya Volkova wants to know whether a drop is the ad or the page. The engagement line answers that before she asks.

In their listNeeds youEngagement fell 61% to 44%: check the page too.

A small shop owner

Daniel Okafor spends a few hundred a week on Meta and checks Ads Manager rarely. Twice a week the list does it for him.

In their listEverything else35 live ads showed no sign.

What Creative fatigue watch connects to

Creative fatigue watch connects to three tools: it reads Meta Ads and Google Analytics and posts one message to Slack. You connect each one yourself, and Toolspoke stores the connection encrypted, so the agent never sees the credential.

What Creative fatigue watch does and cannot do in each connected tool
ToolWhat Creative fatigue watch doesWhat it cannot do
Meta AdsReads ad-level results and the list of live ads (get_insights, list_ads).Pause a campaign if you give it read access. Pausing is the only Meta action that changes anything, and a read-only grant cannot reach it.
Google AnalyticsReads engagement for the visits each ad sent with run_report, and checks fields with check_compatibility.Change anything: every action in the Google Analytics connector is a read.
SlackPosts one message to the channel you chose (send_message).Delete messages: the connector has no delete action. It can edit and schedule messages, and the agent is told to do neither.

Google Analytics is read-only, which is a property of the connector. With Meta installed with read access, the agent cannot pause a campaign either. Every change it points to is one you make in Ads Manager.

If you give the agent more than read access to Meta, never pausing is an instruction, not a lock. The access control guide explains how to keep it to reads.

When Creative fatigue watch runs

Creative fatigue watch runs on Mondays and Thursdays at 9am, but only after you switch its schedule on. It arrives switched off, so nothing runs and nothing is charged until you decide.

  • Each run compares the last 7 days with the 7 before.
  • Only live ads with enough impressions are judged.
  • When nothing is tired, it posts one line.
  • If Meta cannot be read, it posts that once.

Each run uses model credit from your workspace balance, so it makes two runs a week. The Meta, Analytics and Slack calls themselves are free.

Your copy is an ordinary agent in your project. You can pause its schedule there, run it once on demand, change the days and time and edit its instructions. The agent's page lists recent runs and their cost.

How to set up Creative fatigue watch

To catch tired ads twice a week, add Creative fatigue watch to a Toolspoke project, connect Meta Ads, Google Analytics and Slack, say how your ads are tagged and switch on the schedule. Nothing runs until the last step.

  1. Step 1: Create a Toolspoke account or sign in

    Choose Use this agent. If you are new, you will be asked to sign up first, and you come straight back to this agent afterwards.

  2. Step 2: Add it to a project

    Pick the project it should live in. You get your own editable copy, and you can see the three tools it brings before anything connects.

  3. Step 3: Connect Meta Ads with read access

    Choose Sign in with Facebook and pick the ad account. Give the agent read access, so it cannot pause a campaign.

  4. Step 4: Connect Google Analytics

    Choose Sign in with Google and pick the GA4 property your ads send visits to.

  5. Step 5: Connect Slack

    Choose Sign in with Slack and approve the Toolspoke app. For a private channel, add the Toolspoke bot to it first.

  6. Step 6: Say how your ads are tagged

    Name the UTM field that carries the ad, usually utm_content set to the ad name or id, the channel and the frequency that counts as high. Leave it out to use 3.5.

  7. Step 7: Switch on the schedule

    The schedule arrives switched off. Run it once to see a list, then switch it on.

Make Creative fatigue watch fit your account

Creative fatigue watch's instructions are plain English and you can edit them after you install it. Installing copies the agent, so your edits stay with your copy. Open the agent in Toolspoke and tell the builder what to change, and it rewrites the instructions.

Paste any sentence below into the builder chat, or say the same thing in your own words.

Be stricter on retargeting
For ad sets with Retarget in the name, treat frequency 6 as high.
Only big spenders
Only flag ads that spent more than 200 in the last 7 days.
Use a longer window
Compare the last 14 days with the 14 before.
Tag the designer
Mention @kofi at the end of the post when any ad is tired.
Run every weekday
Run every weekday at 9am.

This changes when the agent wakes up, so the builder edits its schedule, not the instructions.

None of these edits needs more access or touches the Never rules. They change what Creative fatigue watch is told, not what the connections allow.

How it compares to other options

Creative fatigue watch beats the alternatives when you want every live ad checked twice a week and the landing page checked alongside. It loses to them when you want ads paused or rotated with nobody in the loop.

Creative fatigue watch compared with Meta's automated rules, Ads Manager columns, A weekly manual check
Compared onCreative fatigue watchMeta's automated rulesAds Manager columnsA weekly manual check
Compares each ad with last weekYesThreshold onlyIf you set the datesYes
Checks the landing page tooYes, in GA4NoNoIf you open Analytics
Arrives in SlackYesNotifications in MetaNoIf you post it
Can pause an ad on its ownNo, with read accessYesNoNo
Rules you can read and changePlain EnglishRule builderNot applicableWhatever you check
Setup effortConnect three accountsA rule per conditionNoneAn hour a week

Meta's automated rules are the better choice when you want a tired ad switched off the moment it crosses a line, with nobody checking first.

Ads Manager columns are enough for a small account you already check daily. Creative fatigue watch suits an account with enough ads that nobody compares each one every week.

Frequently asked questions

Can Creative fatigue watch pause my ads?

Not with read access. Pausing a campaign is the only Meta action that changes anything, and a read-only grant cannot reach it. With wider access, the agent is told never to (how access works).

How does it find the landing page for an ad?

Through the UTM tag your ads carry. Meta's results do not include the landing page, so you say at install which tag names the ad, usually utm_content. Untagged ads are judged on Meta alone.

What counts as fatigue?

A live ad with frequency at or above 3.5 whose click rate fell by a quarter or more on the week before, with at least 1,000 impressions in each week. You can change each number.

Does it work with Google Ads?

No. It reads Meta only. Ad spend waste finder reads both Google Ads and Meta Ads for spend that brought no conversions.

Why does it run twice a week?

A tired ad can waste most of a week's budget before a weekly check catches it. Monday and Thursday catch it within a few days without a post every morning.

Can it change anything in Google Analytics?

No. Every action in the Google Analytics connector is a read.

Is Creative fatigue watch free?

It has no price of its own, and every Toolspoke plan includes agents. Tool calls cost nothing, but each run draws on your usage balance. Pricing has the details.

Replace the ad before it wears out the budget

Connect Meta Ads with read access, Google Analytics and Slack, say how your ads are tagged and switch on the schedule. Your first list lands at 9am on Monday or Thursday.