Toolspoke vs Arcade.dev
Arcade.dev is a tool and authorization layer for agents. It documents 7,500+ tools across 81 MCP servers, handles each end user's OAuth for them, and adds gateways and policy hooks on top. It runs as a managed cloud by default, with Helm and cloud-marketplace installs for larger customers. Pricing follows tool calls, with no per-seat charge.
| Topic | Toolspoke | Arcade.dev |
|---|---|---|
| Self-hosting | Yes. Docker Compose and PostgreSQL 17, on every plan including Free. The gateway self-hosts; hosted agents run on toolspoke.com. | Documented: a Helm install on your own Kubernetes cluster, a managed app on Azure, a private offer on AWS, and workers you run in your own network. The pricing page lists VPC and air-gapped deployment under Enterprise only and says Free and Team are managed on Arcade Cloud. Which plan includes the Helm install is unconfirmed. |
| Credential handling | Yes. Decrypted inside the gateway per call, never reaches the client or the model, on every plan. | Arcade stores each user's OAuth tokens, API keys and secrets. Production volumes use AES-256, with a second AES-256 layer on tokens and secrets. Arcade Cloud runs in the United States only. |
| Audit log | Yes. Every call writes a row (person, arguments, result, timing) on every plan including Free. | Two records. Audit logs cover administrative actions and are on by default. Tool Executions records each tool run with the user, tool and outcome; inputs and outputs are withheld by default and visible to project admins only. Cloud keeps executions for 7 days by default, 90 at most. The pricing page lists audit logs under Enterprise; which plan includes Tool Executions is unconfirmed. |
| Pricing | Free, or $19 per seat/month (Pro) with no seat cap. Tool calls cost nothing; sandbox time and model tokens are billed from usage. | Free ($0, 2,000 tool calls a month), Team ($25/month platform fee plus $0.01 per tool call) or Enterprise (custom, with SSO, RBAC and audit logs listed). There is no per-seat charge. |
| Cost for a 3-seat team | $57/month (3 × Pro seat), with tool calls included. | $25/month plus $0.01 per tool call, the same for 3 people or 30. The pricing page does not say whether any calls are included in the $25. |
| Permissions | Each project switches individual toolkit actions on or off for everyone in it. An agent key is granted projects and can be narrowed to toolkits and named actions, and it never reaches past its owner's access. | Gateways choose which tools a client sees. Contextual Access applies per user, org and project through webhooks your own server answers before and after each call. SSO and RBAC are listed under Enterprise. |
| Hosted agents | Yes. Yes, on toolspoke.com, with project access policies and a complete audit log. They are not part of the self-hosted gateway. | None in the docs checked. Arcade is the tools and auth layer your own agent calls, and Arcade Deploy hosts your MCP server. |
Checked 2026-11-02. Arcade's pricing page and its docs do not say which plan includes the Helm install or Tool Executions, and its August 2025 pricing post describes older limits and rates than the current pricing page. Confirm plan terms with Arcade before a purchase.
Run it yourself
Your own Postgres, your own credential store, your own audit log. Nothing above needs an account with us: the compose file is public, and the image is public on GHCR.
$ curl -fsSL \
https://toolspoke.com/self-host/compose.yaml \
-o compose.self-host.yaml
$ echo "BETTER_AUTH_SECRET=$(openssl rand -base64 32)" \
>> .env
$ echo "CREDENTIALS_ENCRYPTION_KEY=$(openssl rand -base64 32)" \
>> .env
$ docker compose -f compose.self-host.yaml \
up -d
When to pick Arcade.dev instead
- Your product acts for many end users and you want Arcade to run each user's OAuth consent and token storage for you.
- Your headcount is large and your call volume is modest, so usage pricing with no per-seat charge costs less than Toolspoke's per-seat Pro price.
- You want to write your own policy code that runs before and after every tool call, which Arcade's Contextual Access webhooks are built for.
- Your platform team runs Kubernetes and wants a Helm install, or you buy through the Azure or AWS marketplace.
- The 7,500+ tools in Arcade's catalog already cover the systems you need.
Try Toolspoke on your own infrastructure
Start on the hosted Free plan, or self-host it from the start. Either way, the gateway, the credential store and the audit log are the same code.